The Legitimacy of the "Surrogacy" in Light of Neoteric Jurisprudential and Legislative Trends: A Critical Study
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35682/r8ejfv06Keywords:
Surrogacy, Surrogate Mother, Human Trafficking, Reproductive Assistive Techniques, Legal CharacterisationAbstract
This study scrutinises surrogacy as a global industry and its presence in some Arab and foreign legislations, characterised by considerable discrepancies, ranging from unrestrained acceptance of both commercial and altruistic forms, to partial acceptance of one form over another, to utter rejection, which reached a crescendo with criminalisation and punishment. Amid these legislations, the Jordanian legislation stands in a grey area, as it has disallowed all forms of surrogacy, without explicitly mentioning or criminalising it. Hence, this study demonstrates that the lawmaker’s attitude is inextricably linked to the process of determining the civil characterisation of the contract and arrangements associated with it, and the difficulty in establishing the legality of the contract from a civil law perspective may ineluctably lead to its criminalisation. However, this has not been the case in all comparative criminal legislations. Thus, this study comes to place surrogacy or surrogate motherhood as being considered an assisted reproductive technique under the criminal legislation’s microscope. It aims to assess its legitimacy or illegitimacy by exploring whether this technique, in itself, constitutes crimes under the Jordanian Penal Act and other supplementary criminal Laws. The study has concluded that, notwithstanding the scientific community’s recognition as a reliable medical means that pays off scientifically and medically, it has still been posing legal doubts about the validity of the contract made in this regard, as well as misgivings related to its encroachment on legal interests protected through criminalisation and punishment by the penal lawmaker.

